Either you watched the rabbit scene before talking to John and acknowledge the sentimentality that makes you sick, or after you talked to john and was going linearly, saw the rabbit scene and was like “nope, not talking to you then” and back tracked a few minutes

So I was right, Candy Corn confirmed it. John is going to give his rabbit away to the rest of the kids, which is why they had the rabbits to give back to john in the first place.

So were they just shipped out with the rabbits then?